It is appropriate to use a single topic and do a critique of another topic.
The students should understand how to write a compare and contrast essay with a proper structure. Thus, one should know how to analyze ideas effectively. Why? Because this single task gives instructors the possibility to check students’ knowledge and understanding of several theories or several notions, or texts. Looking at the learner’s agenda one can see several compare and contrast titles as this kind of writing is often met in colleges. This is just a form of academic writing where the author juxtaposes two or more ideas. Still, this kind of analysis is not as tricky as it might seem at first glance. They get disappointed when they see tasks with compare and contrast titles in their academic schedule.
It’s not a secret that students hate assignments that include an element of comparative analysis.